Bagels Your Way Cafe
Welcome to Bagels Your Way Cafe, a hidden gem located in Medford, NY. This cafe offers a delightful combination of deli breakfast options, freshly baked bagels, and delectable sandwiches for lunch.
Customers rave about the flavorful breakfast potatoes, perfectly crafted egg sandwiches, and a variety of bakery items that are simply awesome. The customization options available when ordering through an app make the ordering experience even more convenient for patrons.
One customer, Jeanine H., describes Bagels Your Way Cafe as her favorite spot in the area for deli breakfast and bagels. She emphasizes the quality of the food and the wide range of options available. Another customer, Samantha C., appreciates the cafe's efforts to provide delicious bagels in a county known for struggling in that department.
The Dagwood sandwich, a standout item on the menu, is a well-executed creation that combines the flavors of a classic American hero with a unique twist. The addition of salami and Swiss cheese on a hero bun, along with optional toppings like mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, and onions, creates a mouthwatering experience for sandwich enthusiasts.
In addition to savory dishes, Bagels Your Way Cafe also offers sweet treats like cookies stuffed with a Reese's Peanut Butter cup, showcasing their creativity in dessert offerings. The cafe's commitment to providing a pleasant dining experience is evident through their attentive service and surprise additions like pickles and side salads with sandwich orders.
With a cozy dining area and a range of amenities like private lot parking and gender-neutral restrooms, Bagels Your Way Cafe goes above and beyond to cater to their customers' needs. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite on the go or looking for a relaxed dining experience, this cafe is sure to impress with its delicious food and warm hospitality.
Bagels Your Way Cafe Menu
Location
Address: 2799 Rt 112 Medford, NY 11763
Phone: (631) 758-6467
Business info
- Offers TakeoutYes
- Gluten-Free OptionsYes
- Accepts Credit CardsYes
- Accepts Android PayYes
- Accepts Apple PayNo
- Offers CateringYes
- Private Lot ParkingYes
- Gender-neutral restroomsYes
- Bike ParkingYes
Last Reviews
-
Author: Jeanine H.
Our favorite place for deli breakfast and bagels in the area. The breakfast potatoes, bagels and egg sandwiches are so good. All of the fountain drinks and bakery items are awesome too. I also love that when you order on an app they have all of the customization options available.
-
Author: Samantha C.
One of the more decent bagel spots in the area. This might be an unpopular opinion, but Suffolk County has a tough time when it comes to good bagels. The bagels here are comparable to Nassau and one of two spot we grab bagels from when in the area. This time we were in the need of lunch so we grabbed sandwiches. The Dagwood wad one of the most really well done sandwich that I've had in a while. Think of an American hero, add salami and Swiss cheese and throw it on a hero (I like mine with mayo, lettuce, tomatoes and onions). What really would have knocked this sandwich out of the park is if the bread was a tad better. Ordered with our sandwiches were deli iced teas, and two cookies stuffed with a Reese's Peanut Butter cup (genius). The iced teas were a little too sweet. Sometimes when we come here the service is a little meh. This time, however, I was quickly in and out of there and the guy that help me was actually quite pleasant and made everything really good. I didn't realize that our sandwiches came with a pickle and a side salad but those were packed with our sandwiches which was a nice surprise. Cafe is in the title of the name of this spot, so it's no surprise there is a decent amount of tables for dining in. Not a bad pit stop if needed right of the expressway.